Skip to main content

Territorial Responsible Research and Innovation Through the involvement of local R&I Actors

Deliverables

Map of the Territorial Milieux

For each of the five territories involved in the project, an in-depth mapping of the main societal actors present on the territories where the experiments will be developed (territorial mileu) will be carried out. The mapping exercise will be led by the research partners, with the support of the related territorial organisations and will use the tools developed in T2.1. The territorial milieux will be mapped through a scoping review of literature, policy reports and online contents, and through direct consultation of territorial stakeholders. In particular the following aspects will be considered in the mapping of territorial milieu. a) The main actors present on the territories where the experiment will take place. A wide set of actors will be considered including those actors connected with RRI keys (such as women, schools and young people, etc.). The actors will be mapped taking into consideration also their visions, orientations, etc. A mapping template will be developed during the kick-off meeting. The collected information will be stored in a database of actors. b) The RRI initiatives (or any of its 6 keys) already present in the territories selected for the experiments (in some cases the whole region). A mapping template will be developed during the kick-off meeting. The collected information will be stored in a database of RRI practices. c) The “territorial factors” cover social, economic, demographic and cultural risks and emerging opportunities which will be identified and analysed for each of the involved territories. Tool: territorial factors observation grid. d) the main “territorial policies” developed by actors at different level of governance (municipality, regions, national and EU) related with the experiment to be carried out. Tool: territorial policies observation grid. All the maps developed in the 5 territories will be collected in a single document by K&I (D2.2). This task will be articulated into the following subtasks: 2.3.1. Map of Territorial Milieu in Central Macedonia (SEERC; M4 – M8) 2.3.2. Map of Territorial Milieu in Emilia Romagna (K&I; M4 – M8) 2.3.3. Map of Territorial Milieu in Trøndelag (NTNU; M4 – M8) 2.3.4. Map of Territorial Milieu in North-East Romania (ESF; M4 – M8) 2.3.5. Map of Territorial Milieu in Gabrovo (ARC Fund; M4 – M8) 2.3.6. Collection in a comprehensive document of the above mentioned maps (K&I; M8 – M9)

Inventory of RRI governance innovation practices

In this deliverable the knowledge already produced by SwafS - RRI projects will be capitalised in order to identify RRI governance innovation useful in order to develop the transformative experiments. To this end an analysis will be conducted of the final and intermediate results of projects like: FIT4RRI, RRI Tools, RRI practices, STARBIOS2, PROGRESS, RESAGORA, RESPONSIBLE INDUSTRY, FOTRRIS, NUCLEUS, etc. In the task other projects already connecting RRI and S3such as MARIE and THINKING SMART will be analysed.

Map of the state of the art of R&I ecosystem in 5 territorial areas

On the basis of the tools developed in the previous tasks from WP2, for each region the following aspects will be mapped and reported in D2.3: a) Regional R&I assets; b) Research infrastructures; c) Cluster Incubators and Innovation ecosystems; d) Regional scientific production profiles; e) Specialisation indexes; f) SWOT analyses; This task will take into account and complement the existing mapping exercises, and among them the ones produced in framework of Smart Specialisation Platform, the European Cluster Observatory, and the Regional Innovation Scoreboard. On the basis of the results, in each region a “State of the art analysis of R&I ecosystem” will be drafted and a unified report (D2.3 will be produced).

Report on experiences and lessons learned

This report will summarize the mutual learning activities from TeRRItoria and will report the mutual learning activities from Task 71 and Task 72

Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in Central Macedonia Region

Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in Central Macedonia Region which will cover the following concepts Experiment Rationale This transformative experiment will develop and activate a Gender Equality Plan for regional RI systems to cope with the underrepresentation of women and socially excluded groups In fact while the Region of Central Macedonia is characterised by a high degree of RI activities the level of attendance of women in STEM specialisation is still low The same may be said in respect to the representation of women as well as socially excluded groups in the higher management levels of RI in both academia and industry The Regional Gender Equality Plan developed in the experiment will address issues like the gender wage gap the hiring procedures for RI staff at both Academic and industry level the issue of the glass ceiling in RI In parallel the Plan will address similar issues for underrepresented population groups like minorities and people with disabilities Territorial Milieu The experiment will be carried out in the whole region and will involve representatives of Academia Industry and civil society of national government active groups of women other representatives of minorities groups disabilities and citizens Expected change The changes may include a the set up and operation of a Quadruple Helix Action Group on RI Gender and Social Inclusion led by the Directorate of Innovation and Entrepreneurships with the participation of representatives of academia industry and civil society b gender and other inclusion indicators adopted in the monitoring of the implementation of S3 process c impacts on the agenda setting for S3 in the next periods

Evaluation scheme

This deliverable will contain the design of an appropriate evaluation scheme, which is capable of embracing the complexities of the implementation of the TeRRItoria activities as well as handling versatility concerning goals and objectives of these change-oriented activities. To this aim, the scheme will identify the most relevant qualitative and quantitative indicators to be applied. As part of this work, careful consideration of indicators related to the Sustainable Development Goals as well as indicators developed by MoRRI (including, but not limited to, GE1, SLSE1, SLSE4, PE1, PE2, PE5, PE7, PE8, E1, OA6, GOV2) will inform the evaluation scheme for TeRRItoria. Also on this basis a set of sustainability indicators will be developed. The evaluation scheme will be drafted by the task leader and discussed with the Consortium members for revisions and approval.

Map of approaches, policies and tools for Territorial RRI

The Map (i.e report) will identify a “menu” of approaches, policies and tools to be adopted in WP4 for the design of the transformative experiments, and for their implementation in WP5.

Working paper on Territorial RRI

An internal workshop on Territorial RRI will be organised in Bologna at M11, connected to the third steering committee meeting, for sharing within the consortium the results of the Mapping Exercise (WP2 and WP3). The main objective of the workshop would be a reflection on how to adapt RRI concepts and tools to the Territorial level (Territorial RRI) in the experiments. The workshop will be articulated in three section: the first one dedicated to sharing the results of WP1 – Mapping the R&I Ecosystems; the second one dedicated to the presentation of WP2 – Mapping of governance innovation practices; the third one to a discussion with all the partners on how RRI may help to open R&I ecosystems in the 5 territorial areas. The workshop will be carried out on the basis of the Maps developed in WP2 and WP3 and of a draft for discussion. The five RDAs which will be selected by EURADA as third parties will be invited to attend and contribute to the workshop. The results of the workshop will be summarised in a working paper on Territorial RRI (D4.1).

Set of mapping of tools

This deliverable will be devoted to the development of the mapping toolbox to be used in the subsequent task of the WP. The toolbox will encompass two sets of tools:. a) Tools for in-depth mapping of territorial milieu (for Task 2.2): database of actors, a database of RRI practices, territorial risks analysis observation grid, territorial policies observation grid. b) Tools for state of the art analysis on regional R&I system (for task 2.3). The task will take advantage of the tools already developed in the Smart Specialisation Platform, the European Clusters Observatory, the Regional Innovation Scoreboard and Online S3. The tools will be developed by ARC Fund with the help of K&I. A specific session of the Kick-off meeting will be devoted to discuss the preparation of the two sets of tools. On the basis of the outcome of the discussion, the final version of the toolbox will be delivered in M4.

Ethics and Gender-Balance Management Plan

Develop a guideline for ethics & diversity gender monitoring during the project implementation. At the kick off meeting a responsible will be named who will be in charge for addressing all this matters and to report to the SC and the GA. This will lead to the establishment of an Ethics Committee within TeRRItoria.

Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in North-East Romania

Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in NorthEast Romania which will contain the following concepts Experiment Rationale The mountain area of our NE Romania presents a number of economic and social disadvantages Organic food production may have a pivotal role in facing these social challenges and thus agrofood sector and the subsector of safefood production are among the priority intervention areas of RIS3 NorthEast In this context the experiment will develop a a platform for innovation brokerage between local population innovators and facilitators to fosters development through innovation at communitymicroregion level b consultative instrument to identify and prioritize needs of innovation in communities c a number of concrete RRI interventions to be implemented in selected spots of the selected territoriesTerritorial Milieu The experiment will be conducted in two local communities Vatra Dornei and CeahlauDamuc areas from the mountain area of NorthEast Romania Among the actors to be involved there are NorthEast Romanias Regional Development Agency CEMONT a knowledge research centre located in Vatra Dornei local association of producers and a Local Action Group consisting of public and private actors from the area local SMEs etc Expected change a Institutional change in the organisation involved in the development and administration of the platform beyond the end of the project b Permanent adoption of the consultative tool leading to change in agenda setting at the local level c a set concrete change in the territory involved

Inventory of bottom-up governance innovation practices

This deliverable consists of an inventory of governance innovation practices selected among the bottom-up experiences connected with the R&I societal challenges not necessarily labeled under RRI. The sources will be: academic and grey literature, the results of SEISMIC project (collecting a number of social innovations divided for field of application and country), European databases dedicated to different fields: Concerto, ManagEnergy, Energy Cities, Intelligent Energy (Energy); Civitas, Eltis (Mobility), Build-Up, Climate ADAPT (Environment), etc.

First video stories

The video stories will contain dissemination extracts from all the key points of the project implementation

Project website

The website will be designed in accordance with the visual project identity, and all the public project materials will be accessible from the website, which will also cross-link from/to other channels used for the project. It will be maintained and updated until the end of the project and kept alive for at least 3 years after the natural contractual end of the project.

Searching for OpenAIRE data...

Publications

TeRRitoria D4.2 Outline of the 5 territorial Transformative Experiments

Author(s): Jakobsen, Julia; Jørgensen, Marie Louise
Published in: 3, 2021
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526561

TeRRItoria D4.1 Working paper on Territorial RRI

Author(s): Mezzana, Daniele; Caiati, Giovanni; Berliri, Maresa
Published in: 4, 2020
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526554

TeRRItoria D7.2 - TeRRItoria Policy Recommendations for embedding RRI into the R&I development cycle

Author(s): Eleftherakis, George; Michali, Maria; Zaharis, Nikos
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6219152

TeRRitoria D5.5 - Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in the Municipality of Gabrovo

Author(s): Koleva, Desislava; Nenkova, Sevdalina
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6089634

TeRRitoria D5.4 - Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in North-East Romania

Author(s): Filimon, Agatha; Rey, Radu; Mitrea, Claudiu
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6089575

TeRRItoria D3.3 Map of approaches, policies and tools for Territorial RRI

Author(s): Caiati, Giovanni; Mezzana, Daniele
Published in: 1, 2019
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526545

TeRRitoria D4.3 Report on the European and International exchanges and synergies

Author(s): Brandstetter-Kunc, Adam; Ipolyi, Ildiko; Lesur, Marion
Published in: 2021
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526578

TeRRitoria D1.2 Ethics and Gender Balance Management Plan

Author(s): Lesur, Marion
Published in: 2, 2019
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526603

TeRRItoria D5.3 - Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in Trøndelag

Author(s): Berker, Thomas; Foslie, Gleny
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6089521

TeRRItoria D3.1 Inventory of bottom-up governance innovation practices

Author(s): Mezzana, Daniele; Caiati, Giovanni; Berliri, Maresa; Signore, Paolo
Published in: 1, 2019
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526024

TeRRItoria D3.2 Inventory of RRI governance innovation practices

Author(s): Eleftherakis, George; Zaharis, Nikos; Michali , Maria
Published in: 1, 2019
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526532

TeRRitoria D7.1 - Report on experiences and lessons learned

Author(s): Michali, Maria; Eleftherakis, George
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6089686

TeRRItoria D6.1 Evaluation Scheme

Author(s): Ravn, Tine; Christensen, Malene Vinther
Published in: 1, 2020
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526581

TeRRItoria D2.3 Map of the state of the art of R&I ecosystem in 5 territorial areas

Author(s): Brandstetter-Kunc, Adam
Published in: 1, 2019
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5525949

TeRRItoria D6.2 Formative Evaluation

Author(s): Christensen, Malene Vinther; Ravn, Tine
Published in: 1, 2021
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5526594

TeRRItoria D2.2 Map of the Territorial Milieux

Author(s): Kozarev, Ventseslav; Damianova, Zoya
Published in: 2, 2019
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5525915

TeRRItoria D6.3 - Summative evaluation report

Author(s): Christensen, Malene Vinther; Ravn, Tine; Mezzana, Daniele; Berliri, Maresa
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6282018

TeRRItoria D5.1 - Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in the Region of Central Macedonia

Author(s): Pantazi, Kallitsa; Pappa, Eleni
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6089288

TeRRItoria D2.1 Set of Mapping Tools

Author(s): Kozarev, Ventseslav; Mezzana, Daniele
Published in: 4, 2019
Publisher: TeRRitoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5525893

TeRRItoria D5.2 - Report and sustainability plan of the Transformative Experiment in Emilia-Romagna

Author(s): Mancinone Kristian
Published in: 2022
Publisher: TeRRItoria
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6089394

Evaluative conversations: Translating between diverse stakeholders in regional RRI projects

Author(s): Holtrop, Tjitske and Meijer, Ingeborg and Otero-Hermida, Paula and Amanatidis, Anestis and Buongiovanni, Chiara and Casale, Donatella and Colonnello, Claudia and Deserti, Alessandro and Feudo, Fabio and Hartman, Alan and Hörlesberger, Marianne and Ipolyi, Ildiko M. and Nguyen, Nhien and Nieminen, Mika and Quinti, Gabriele and Ravn, Tine and Rizzo, Francesca and Schmittinger, Felicitas and Steinha
Published in: The Proceedings of the REvaluation Conference 2021|22, fteval Journal for Research and Technology Policy Evaluation (53), 2022, Page(s) pp. 77-84, ISSN 1726-6629
Publisher: fteval
DOI: 10.22163/fteval.2022.544

Responsible Public Engagement at Territorial LevelCore Dimensions and Means for Implementation

Author(s): Maria Michali ; Thalia Kallia ; Daniele Mezzana ; George Eleftherakis
Published in: [New] Normal Technology Ethics: Proceedings of the ETHICOMP 2021, 2021, Page(s) 206-208, ISBN 978-84-09-28671-3
Publisher: Universidad de La Rioja

Bridging the Gender Gap in Stem Disciplines

Author(s): Maria Michali ; George Eleftherakis
Published in: Paradigm Shifts in ICT Ethics: Proceedings of the ETHICOMP* 2020, 2020, Page(s) 69-72, ISBN 978-84-09-20272-0
Publisher: Universidad de La Rioja

Responsible Public Engagement at Territorial LevelCore Dimensions and Means for Implementation

Author(s): Maria Michali ; Thalia Kallia ; Daniele Mezzana ; George Eleftherakis
Published in: Moving technology ethics at the forefront of society, organisations and governments, 2021, Page(s) 347-358, ISBN 978-84-09-28672-0
Publisher: Universidad de La Rioja