To identify etiologically-relevant neuro-subtypes of autism, we have selected 19 mouse lines harboring a wide variety of genetic mutations associated with autism and mapped the corresponding patterns of brain activity using fMRI, a brain imaging method that can be equally applied in humans and in rodents. The use of several genetically distinct mutants allowed us to represent aspects of autism heterogeneity, while the use of rodents allowed us to map the brain imaging under the tight control of genetic and environmental factors in a way that is unattainable in human research. These controlled investigations revealed that genetic mutations associated with autism produce a range of different brain alterations. Despite this variability, we identified two dominant patterns of altered brain activity, one characterized by functional over-communication among brain regions and the other by functional under-communication. Guided by our mouse findings, we decoded rsfMRI connectivity brain maps of individuals with idiopathic autism, and we found two subtypes of participants recapitulating the dominant hypo- and hyper-connectivity brain patterns that we identified in the rodent database. We then carried out the same decoding analysis in an independent dataset of brain scans of people with autism, and we found high replicability of our subtypes. Importantly, participants in the hyper-connected subtype showed more severe socio-communicative symptoms compared to those in the hypo-connected subtype.