"Materiality and Cosmology in Plato and the Platonic Tradition" is a project in history of philosophy. It was motivated by the need to examine more closely Plato's own understanding of materiality, or better, corporeality, as presented in his probably most influential work, the Timaeus, but also to emphasize that, already from the time of his disciple Aristotle, philosophers have been working with a mistaken interpretation of Plato's views. This was, curiously, also true of the Platonists that came after the master. Following Aristotle, they misidentified and misinterpreted Plato's suspected "principles of corporeality", namely the so-called Necessity and Space of the Timaeus. In short, this project's three main objectives are:
1) To critically examine Plutarch’s, Plotinus’, and Proclus’ theories of matter (as derived from their interpretation of Plato’s Necessity and Space) and to demonstrate that they are, in a sense, more faithful to Aristotle than to Plato. 2) To establish that the closest equivalent of causa materialis in the Timaeus is Necessity, and not Space. Consequently, if one wants to designate something in Timaeus as “Plato’s matter”, that something should be Necessity and not Space; nevertheless, such an attribution would be anachronistic, because Plato does not operate with the notion of matter, but with that of corporeality instead. 3) Therefore, it is impossible for Space, which is manifestly different from Necessity, to play the same role. In other words, Space cannot be "that out of which", but only "that in which" the world has been fashioned.
This project aims at filling the gap within scholarly literature on Platonism by identifying clearly the error committed by the ancient Platonist and the possible causes behind it, as well as by arguing for a novel, hopefully plausible, interpretation of Plato's views on corporeality and cosmology. Its main outcome will be a monograph on the subject.