As governments increasingly turn to artificial intelligence (AI) and automated systems to manage public life, including taxation, social benefit allocation, and processing visa applications, a fundamental question arises: how individuals evaluate legitimacy of algorithmic governance and how their judgments change?
Current research often assumes that people evaluate technology through a deliberate, rational process, weighing transparency and fairness against efficiency. However, in reality, humans often rely on mental shortcuts, or heuristics, to make sense of complex systems. The AGAPP project addresses the critical gap between how we think people should judge automated governance systems and how they actually do it.
The core objective of AGAPP is to move beyond abstract theories of "axiomatic rationality" to develop the Legitimation Heuristic Model (LHM). This model explains how situated contexts and cognitive biases—such as the tendency to stick with the "status quo" or to substitute complex information by “gut feelings”—shape public perception of algorithmic governance.
By integrating insights from political science and cognitive psychology, the project aims to:
1) Investigate heuristic repertoires in evaluating legitimacy of algorithmic governance;
2) Examine how cue availability conditions legitimacy judgments;
3) Explore the contextual dynamics of legitimacy judgments.
Using rigorous qualitative and experimental methods, AGAPP will address these objectives to provide a new theoretical understanding of perceived legitimacy of algorithmic governance and generate knowledge on mechanisms and dynamics of legitimacy evaluations more generally.