Periodic Reporting for period 2 - Mideast Med (A regional history of medicine in the modern Middle East, 1830-1960)
Reporting period: 2019-03-01 to 2020-08-31
MidEastMed explores six analytic cores.
1. The global context: global vectors of disease transmission, alongside the transmission of medical knowledge and expertise. We examine, for example, global bodies of knowledge, and the global, regional and local medical challenges of the era of global mobility.
2. The international aspect: how international conventions and international bodies affected the region and were affected by it.
3. The regional flow of both health challenges and proposed solutions, the regional spread of epidemics and the formation of regional epistemic communities.
4. The colonial aspect, noting both inter- and intra-colonial influences, and the encounter between colonial bodies of knowledge and locally produced ones.
5. The role played by doctors in various national projects: the nahda, namely the Arabic literary revival; the Zionist project; Egyptian and Syrian interwar nationalism and Arab nationalism.
6. The social history of medical encounters. Spread across a wide expanse of space and time, we endeavor to portray a long-term narrative of interactions between local societies and modern medicine.
The project has organized a day conference on the topic of “The Doctor, the Library and the Archive: Multidisciplinary Gaze on Medicine” (Jerusalem, 2018) and a 3-day workshop on “Medical Mobilities in the Middle East and North Africa, 1830-1960” (Nazareth, 2019). Team members have organized panels at the following major conferences: WOCMES 2018 (""Mediators, Medicine and Coloniality: The Middle East and the Maghreb in the 19th and 20th Centuries""), MESA 2018 (""Doctors and Discourse: Medical Themes in the Arab Nahda"") and 2019 (""Medicine on the Move: Medical Agents Crossing Borders""), Middle East and Islamic Studies Association of Israel (MEISAI) Annual Conference 2017 (""Healing and Working: Physicians in the Arab World in Modern Times""), 2018 (""Body, Medicine and Establishment at the Beginning of the 20th Century: Discourse and Practice""), and 2019 (""Society, Nation and Government in Interwar Egypt""); as well as presenting their work at smaller conferences and workshops in Israel, Spain, Germany, and the UK.
Subsequently, articles were submitted on the history of colonial nursing in interwar Cyprus and Palestine; the nurse and Arabist Kulthum ‘Awda, between Palestine and the Soviet Union; the connection between doctors and literary writing during the Arab nahḍa; aspects of glocalization in the body of Arabic discourse on tuberculosis,1882-1924; and the management of Israel’s medical cadre by the Hebrew University’s medical school, 1948-1967.
Team members have visited archives in London, Paris and Nantes.
Team members have completed five MA theses, and two of these won national awards.
The project website presents the team's work. A password protected part, which will be open to the public by mid-2022, is the database of medical personnel active in the Middle East and North Africa, 1830-1960. It currently includes information on over 4000 health professionals, over 990 medical and educational institutions and 165 organizations, in almost 900 cities in every inhabited continent and in 336 sources.
Finally, outreach activity included:
1. Academic consultation to an exhibition on the history of Rambam Hospital in Haifa, held in the Haifa Municipal Museum in February-August 2019, and co-authorship of the exhibition's trilingual catalogue.
2. Gamification: We created two educational games: a card game, designed to teach students key terms in the history of epidemics, medical discoveries and local history of medicine; and a board game simulating a 1900 pilgrimage to Mecca designed to teach students about the medical and logistical challenges of turn-of-the-century mobility.
3. Press: The PI and several team members were interviewed and published short historical texts in the general press."
Following our 2019 workshop, the team is currently guest-editing two special issues: “Gender and the Struggle over the Medical Profession in the Middle East,” for Journal of Middle East Women’s Studies, and “Medical Mobilities of the Middle East and North Africa,” for Bulletin of the History of Medicine.
Research output will include a MA thesis, on scientific medicine and physicians in the Islamic reformist thought of early 20th-century Egypt, and 5 PhD dissertations: on Jewish women’s religious practices in light of the encounter with scientific medicine; gynecology and obstetrics in French North Africa; a social history of cholera in the Ottoman Empire; the League of Nations’ Health Organization and the WHO in the Middle East; a history of urbanism in north Palestine via health and sanitation issues.
Articles in preparation include products from MA dissertations, early findings of PhD dissertations, and products of my own and post-doctoral fellows’ research. Topics include the first Ottoman Red Crescent Exhibition; medical students at the Hebrew University’s medical school; the Haifa government hospital; the medicalization of Jewish ritual impurity and purification; Kulthum ‘Awda’s transnational journey; British nurses in Mandate Palestine; a history of the encounter of traditional pharmacopeias with modern pharmacy in 19th- and early 20th-century Egypt.
The dissertations and articles require multiple archival visits (to Nantes, Aix-en-Provence, Geneva and Istanbul), and multiple languages (Arabic, Hebrew, French, Ottoman Turkish and Ladino).
In 2021, we are planning a second international workshop that will bring our project into conversations with historians of medicine of other regions of the Global South.
Future outreach include:
1. Collaboration with medical institutions: exhibition and lectures to the public.
2. Guided tours: an app-based self-guided tour on the history of medicine in Jerusalem, Haifa and Nazareth.
3. Teaching the history of medicine in the Middle East at the Hebrew University’s medical school.