Forty-two PAB-LAB (propionibacteria/lactobacilli) associations were tested by ITFF-ITG in Emmental cheese making following the make procedure : ripening of partially skimmed milk for 1h at 32 C with Streptococcus thermophilus ITG ST82/87 (ITTFF, La Roche sur Foron, France), 30 min total clotting time, cooking the mixed whey and curd particles for 35 min at 53 C, pressing for 6 h at a temperature decreasing to 30 C, salting for 48h at 12 C, ripening for 15 days at 12 C, followed by 15 days at 15 C and then at least 30 days in the delbrueckii subsp, lactis ITG LL51 and P. freudenreichii ITG P23 were used as reference pair. Pairs from the following list were used in different experiments :Lb helveticus ITG LH41, LH56, LH192, LH1 (from ITFF La Roche sur Foron, France), LHB230 (Valio, Helsinki, Finland), Lb delbruecki subsp, lactis ITG LL51, LL57, LL69, LL205, LL229, LL230, and P freudenreichii ITG P1, P14, P18, P23 from (ITFF Rennes, France) and P131 from Valio. Cheeses were judged by a group of ten experts, normally used by ITFF-ITG in it quality control framework, for odour, smell and texture characteristics.
This study of the quality of 150 Emmental cheeses made with 42 different pairs of LAB/PAB allowed the partners to build a technical typology of pairs PAB/LAB as a function of the level of propionic acid fermentation obtained in cheese. The statistical interpretation of quality data by multifactorial analysis (automatic hierarchical classification, factorial analysis) led to the constitution of statically homogenous groups of cheeses. For example on taste : the multifactorial sensorial analysis allowed us to identify 5 groups of cheeses according to their taste. For example : group 5 with piquant and acid tastes (gathering the cheeses made with the strains ITG LH 56 and ITG P14 or ITG P18); group 1 with cheeses without piquant or a bitter taste made (VALIO P131 and ITG LL51). About texture : the interpretation of the texture score showed that the cheeses are grouped essentially according to the lactobacilli species used. The clearest results were obtained with the odour patterns where cheeses are well grouped according to PAB