Periodic Reporting for period 1 - DEPICT (A digitised approach to the political history of early modern critique (1500-1700))
Período documentado: 2024-09-01 hasta 2026-08-31
Resumen del contexto y de los objetivos generales del proyecto
“Critique” is a fundamental notion of modern European societies, closely associated with the capacities to “think for oneself” and to question or resist authority. Yet, despite its importance in education, intellectual life and public debate, the specifically political history through which critique acquired these meanings remains underexplored. DEPICT (A Digitised Approach to the Political History of Early Modern Critique, 1500–1700) addresses this problem by investigating the socio-economic, confessional and political conditions in which the concept of critique emerged and was mobilised in sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Europe. In doing so, the project seeks to historicise assumptions about critique that continue to structure contemporary European intellectual and political culture.
DEPICT pursues three interconnected objectives: (1) to establish a comprehensive bibliography of early modern publications featuring the notion of critique on their title pages; (2) to reconstruct a digitally enhanced prosopography of the authors, editors, translators and publishers involved in its conceptualisation and circulation, paying particular attention to their socio-economic, confessional and political characteristics; and (3) to examine the ideological stakes of a paradigmatic seventeenth-century “critical quarrel” between Richard Simon and Jean Le Clerc. The project is firmly rooted in the social sciences and humanities: it combines intellectual history, book history and the history of concepts with historical sociology, political philosophy and digital humanities, bringing quantitative and relational approaches into dialogue with contextual and textual interpretation.
The project’s pathway to impact connects new research resources, methodological innovation and public engagement. Its bibliographic and prosopographic datasets and scholarly publications are designed to provide reusable resources for researchers, while its combination of book history, conceptual history and digitally enhanced prosopography offers a methodology that can be transferred to the study of other concepts and intellectual formations. Beyond academia, DEPICT aims to foster awareness of the historically contingent ideological assumptions and political implications embedded in concepts used in contemporary public debate. Through open-access dissemination and public-facing communication, the project therefore contributes both to the digital transformation of humanities research and to the wider European objective of ensuring the free and open circulation of knowledge.
DEPICT pursues three interconnected objectives: (1) to establish a comprehensive bibliography of early modern publications featuring the notion of critique on their title pages; (2) to reconstruct a digitally enhanced prosopography of the authors, editors, translators and publishers involved in its conceptualisation and circulation, paying particular attention to their socio-economic, confessional and political characteristics; and (3) to examine the ideological stakes of a paradigmatic seventeenth-century “critical quarrel” between Richard Simon and Jean Le Clerc. The project is firmly rooted in the social sciences and humanities: it combines intellectual history, book history and the history of concepts with historical sociology, political philosophy and digital humanities, bringing quantitative and relational approaches into dialogue with contextual and textual interpretation.
The project’s pathway to impact connects new research resources, methodological innovation and public engagement. Its bibliographic and prosopographic datasets and scholarly publications are designed to provide reusable resources for researchers, while its combination of book history, conceptual history and digitally enhanced prosopography offers a methodology that can be transferred to the study of other concepts and intellectual formations. Beyond academia, DEPICT aims to foster awareness of the historically contingent ideological assumptions and political implications embedded in concepts used in contemporary public debate. Through open-access dissemination and public-facing communication, the project therefore contributes both to the digital transformation of humanities research and to the wider European objective of ensuring the free and open circulation of knowledge.
Trabajo realizado desde el comienzo del proyecto hasta el final del período abarcado por el informe y los principales resultados hasta la fecha
The main scientific activity of DEPICT consisted in the systematic construction and curation of the Corpus Criticorum (c. 1450–1700), an enumerative bibliography and research dataset of early modern publications whose titles or title pages contain forms of the critique word-family. The research combined large-scale interrogation of major European bibliographical resources with manual bibliographical verification. The British Library’s ISTC and the Universal Short Title Catalogue were used as the principal chronological anchors, supplemented by national and language-specific catalogues across Europe. Controlled searches generated 11,890 candidate records, each of which was manually examined, validated or discarded. This resulted in a corpus of 826 publications. Particular attention was paid to discrepancies between modern catalogue records and the material evidence of early modern title pages; bibliographic descriptions were consistently checked against digitised or physical exemplars, following the classical bibliographical sequence of identification, location and examination.
The retained records were then systematically curated and enriched. For each publication, the project collected or verified the full title-page transcription, authors and other contributors, date and place of publication, imprint statement and format. Additional research metadata were added to support historical analysis, including a three-level classification according to the early modern Système des libraires de Paris, the location of publication within both present-day and historical political entities, and the predominant confession of the place of publication. Unique identifiers were assigned to both publications and persons, and authority identifiers such as VIAF, GND and IdRef were incorporated where available. The resulting data were structured into interconnected Work, Instance, Persons-and-Contributions, and Political-and-Confessional-Geography datasets. In parallel, the project has identified the individuals involved in the production and circulation of the Corpus, i.e. authors, editors, translators, printers, publishers and booksellers. The principal remaining task for this component is the systematic enrichment of these person records with socio-economic, confessional and political metadata so that the prosopographical dimension of DEPICT can be fully exploited.
A further technical achievement was the construction of a dedicated research environment for analysing the Corpus. The web application developed in collaboration with the University of Oxford’s Centre for Digital Scholarship uses a three-tier architecture: a MySQL relational database at the data layer, a stateless RESTful API implemented in PHP at the logic layer, and an Angular single-page application at the presentation layer. It permits interactive searching and filtering of the corpus and dynamically generates statistical visualisations, including chronological graphs, aggregate distributions and an interactive map of publication places. The platform therefore provides an integrated environment in which qualitative examination of individual publications can be combined with quantitative analysis of the corpus as a whole.
The completed bibliographical work has already produced substantive historiographical results. Chronologically, the data show that only 46 of the 826 publications (around 5%) predate 1600, while the use of the critique word-family accelerates markedly from the mid-seventeenth century onwards. This cautions against accounts that locate the decisive formation of critique primarily in Renaissance Humanism. Geographically, the Corpus records publications in 139 European cities, with Paris (165 publications), London (85) and Amsterdam (68) as the largest individual centres, but analysis at the level of historical political entities identifies the Holy Roman Empire (210 publications) as the principal geographical concentration, followed by France (193), the Dutch Republic (116) and England (84). The confessional distribution is similarly significant: approximately 62% of the publications appeared in predominantly Protestant territories and 37% in predominantly Roman Catholic ones, suggesting that critique developed through distinct political-confessional ecologies rather than as a homogeneous pan-European phenomenon. Finally, classification of the corpus by contemporary discursive categories shows the continuing importance of religion: Theology accounts for 214 publications, while a substantial proportion of texts classified under History also concern sacred or ecclesiastical subjects. Rather than progressively disappearing, publications connected with theological and religious controversy increased during the seventeenth century and peaked towards its end.
A methodological preprint has been prepared on the basis of this work, documenting the constitution and curation of the Corpus and presenting these initial historiographical findings. Its results are being developed along two complementary scientific trajectories: a data paper documenting the Corpus as a reusable research dataset, and an intellectual-history article analysing what its chronology, geography and discursive distribution imply for established narratives about the origins and development of early modern critique.
The retained records were then systematically curated and enriched. For each publication, the project collected or verified the full title-page transcription, authors and other contributors, date and place of publication, imprint statement and format. Additional research metadata were added to support historical analysis, including a three-level classification according to the early modern Système des libraires de Paris, the location of publication within both present-day and historical political entities, and the predominant confession of the place of publication. Unique identifiers were assigned to both publications and persons, and authority identifiers such as VIAF, GND and IdRef were incorporated where available. The resulting data were structured into interconnected Work, Instance, Persons-and-Contributions, and Political-and-Confessional-Geography datasets. In parallel, the project has identified the individuals involved in the production and circulation of the Corpus, i.e. authors, editors, translators, printers, publishers and booksellers. The principal remaining task for this component is the systematic enrichment of these person records with socio-economic, confessional and political metadata so that the prosopographical dimension of DEPICT can be fully exploited.
A further technical achievement was the construction of a dedicated research environment for analysing the Corpus. The web application developed in collaboration with the University of Oxford’s Centre for Digital Scholarship uses a three-tier architecture: a MySQL relational database at the data layer, a stateless RESTful API implemented in PHP at the logic layer, and an Angular single-page application at the presentation layer. It permits interactive searching and filtering of the corpus and dynamically generates statistical visualisations, including chronological graphs, aggregate distributions and an interactive map of publication places. The platform therefore provides an integrated environment in which qualitative examination of individual publications can be combined with quantitative analysis of the corpus as a whole.
The completed bibliographical work has already produced substantive historiographical results. Chronologically, the data show that only 46 of the 826 publications (around 5%) predate 1600, while the use of the critique word-family accelerates markedly from the mid-seventeenth century onwards. This cautions against accounts that locate the decisive formation of critique primarily in Renaissance Humanism. Geographically, the Corpus records publications in 139 European cities, with Paris (165 publications), London (85) and Amsterdam (68) as the largest individual centres, but analysis at the level of historical political entities identifies the Holy Roman Empire (210 publications) as the principal geographical concentration, followed by France (193), the Dutch Republic (116) and England (84). The confessional distribution is similarly significant: approximately 62% of the publications appeared in predominantly Protestant territories and 37% in predominantly Roman Catholic ones, suggesting that critique developed through distinct political-confessional ecologies rather than as a homogeneous pan-European phenomenon. Finally, classification of the corpus by contemporary discursive categories shows the continuing importance of religion: Theology accounts for 214 publications, while a substantial proportion of texts classified under History also concern sacred or ecclesiastical subjects. Rather than progressively disappearing, publications connected with theological and religious controversy increased during the seventeenth century and peaked towards its end.
A methodological preprint has been prepared on the basis of this work, documenting the constitution and curation of the Corpus and presenting these initial historiographical findings. Its results are being developed along two complementary scientific trajectories: a data paper documenting the Corpus as a reusable research dataset, and an intellectual-history article analysing what its chronology, geography and discursive distribution imply for established narratives about the origins and development of early modern critique.
Avances que van más allá del estado de la técnica e impacto potencial esperado (incluida la repercusión socioeconómica y las implicaciones sociales más amplias del proyecto hasta la fecha)
DEPICT has produced the Corpus Criticorum (c. 1450–1700), a comprehensive bibliographical corpus of early modern publications featuring the notion of critique in their titles or on their title pages. The corpus currently comprises 826 early modern publications, for which bibliographical, linguistic, geographical and classificatory metadata have been systematically collected and curated. A first version of the resulting open dataset has been deposited in the EU Open Research Repository on Zenodo (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17620197). It consists of interconnected datasets describing works and editions, persons and their contributions, and the political and confessional geography of publications. The data use a simplified BIBFRAME Work/Instance/Agent structure and external Linked Open Data identifiers, facilitating their reuse in bibliographical, historical and Digital Humanities research. This considerably extends the initial research base envisaged in DEPICT and provides an empirical foundation for studying the chronology, geography and disciplinary contexts in which critique became established as an early modern concept. The project has also developed a dedicated online research platform at critica.huma-num.fr allowing the corpus and its metadata to be explored interactively.
The project has furthermore identified 1419 individuals involved in the production and circulation of critique in the early modern period - authors, editors, translators, printers, publishers and booksellers. The remaining work consists principally in enriching these authority records with systematic socio-economic, confessional and political metadata so that the prosopographical component can be fully exploited for analysing the social and political coordinates of early modern critique. This work builds directly on DEPICT's interdisciplinary combination of intellectual history, book history, historical sociology and Digital Humanities, which was conceived to move beyond histories centred on a small number of canonical thinkers and towards a collective and empirically grounded history of the people and institutions involved in the agonistic conceptualisations of early modern critical thought. In parallel, a methodological preprint has been prepared describing the constitution of the Corpus Criticorum and presenting its principal historiographical results. It will provide the basis for two complementary peer-reviewed publications: a data paper documenting and facilitating scholarly reuse of the Corpus, and an intellectual-history article interpreting the principal historical findings.
The principal expected impact is therefore scientific and methodological. The dataset and research platform provide reusable infrastructure for historians of concepts, intellectual historians, book historians and Digital Humanities researchers, while the project demonstrates how large-scale bibliographical evidence can be combined with prosopography and contextual interpretation in the history of ideas. This methodology is potentially transferable to the historical study of other concepts and intellectual formations, as originally envisaged in DEPICT. Further uptake will depend primarily on (i) completing the socio-political and confessional enrichment of the prosopographical dataset, (ii) ensuring sustainable maintenance, documentation and long-term accessibility of the research platform and datasets, (iii) publishing the methodological/data paper and the interpretative intellectual-history article, and (iv) further disseminating the resources within relevant international research communities. Commercialisation, market access and proprietary IPR are not relevant objectives for DEPICT; on the contrary, the Corpus Criticorum has been released under a CC BY 4.0 licence, and long-term impact depends on maintaining its open, interoperable and reusable character.
The project has furthermore identified 1419 individuals involved in the production and circulation of critique in the early modern period - authors, editors, translators, printers, publishers and booksellers. The remaining work consists principally in enriching these authority records with systematic socio-economic, confessional and political metadata so that the prosopographical component can be fully exploited for analysing the social and political coordinates of early modern critique. This work builds directly on DEPICT's interdisciplinary combination of intellectual history, book history, historical sociology and Digital Humanities, which was conceived to move beyond histories centred on a small number of canonical thinkers and towards a collective and empirically grounded history of the people and institutions involved in the agonistic conceptualisations of early modern critical thought. In parallel, a methodological preprint has been prepared describing the constitution of the Corpus Criticorum and presenting its principal historiographical results. It will provide the basis for two complementary peer-reviewed publications: a data paper documenting and facilitating scholarly reuse of the Corpus, and an intellectual-history article interpreting the principal historical findings.
The principal expected impact is therefore scientific and methodological. The dataset and research platform provide reusable infrastructure for historians of concepts, intellectual historians, book historians and Digital Humanities researchers, while the project demonstrates how large-scale bibliographical evidence can be combined with prosopography and contextual interpretation in the history of ideas. This methodology is potentially transferable to the historical study of other concepts and intellectual formations, as originally envisaged in DEPICT. Further uptake will depend primarily on (i) completing the socio-political and confessional enrichment of the prosopographical dataset, (ii) ensuring sustainable maintenance, documentation and long-term accessibility of the research platform and datasets, (iii) publishing the methodological/data paper and the interpretative intellectual-history article, and (iv) further disseminating the resources within relevant international research communities. Commercialisation, market access and proprietary IPR are not relevant objectives for DEPICT; on the contrary, the Corpus Criticorum has been released under a CC BY 4.0 licence, and long-term impact depends on maintaining its open, interoperable and reusable character.