Skip to main content
Go to the home page of the European Commission (opens in new window)
English en
CORDIS - EU research results
CORDIS

Death, Smoke, and Mirrors: Manipulation of Health Data in Liberal and Authoritarian Custodial Institutions

Project description

Health reports in liberal and soviet prisons

The concealment of prisoners’ poor health by penal authorities, often for political or bureaucratic reasons, remains an understudied phenomenon across different historical periods and geopolitical contexts. The ERC-funded DeathAndManipulation project will examine how prison and camp authorities in Britain, India, Soviet Russia, and the US have manipulated health statistics from the late modern era to the present. By analysing techniques used to obscure prisoner mortality, the project will uncover patterns of bureaucratic control. It will investigate cases of medical malpractice and systemic neglect, providing a history of how custodial institutions have downplayed sickness and epidemics. This research intends to offer new insights into incarceration, health, and state power.

Objective

"
This project’s overarching theme is how penal authorities conceal the prisoners’ poor health with malicious intent for various reasons and by various techniques, statistical and rhetorical. From this angle, the project examines British metropolitan, Indian colonial, American, and Soviet-Russian prisons and camps from the late modern era – the birth of the Western penitentiary - to the present moment. Within this ambitious temporal and spatial frame, the project poses ""big questions"" about the universal operational patterns of modern penality and bureaucracy, as observed via managing prisoners’ health and epidemics. The project seeks to understand why and when prisoner health statistics became significant enough to be manipulated for political purposes. Conceptually, the project engages with the contentious issue of deliberate extermination of prisoners concealed by medical malfeasance. The outcome will be the first comparative, integrated history of bureaucratic malpractices to occasionally downplay the accurate scale of sickness, epidemics, and mortality in custodial institutions of Western liberal and authoritarian regimes. The interdisciplinary research effort, while historical, combines insights from medical statistics, penology, criminology, penal sociology, and bioethics.

The ambition behind the project’s goals is to revise the traditional way literature classifies penal systems globally. This revision is achieved by shifting attention to health and its reporting as a defining feature that separates various carceral regimes from each other. The project will generate a new typology of penal systems based on the criterion of health reporting and its veracity. Beyond the strictly academic contribution to the debates on penality, modernity, technocratic social engineering, legacies of colonial violence, and total institutions, the project has implications for international prison reform and palliative care ethics.
"

Fields of science (EuroSciVoc)

Keywords

Programme(s)

Topic(s)

Funding Scheme

HORIZON-ERC - HORIZON ERC Grants

See all projects funded under this funding scheme

Call for proposal

(opens in new window) ERC-2024-STG

See all projects funded under this call

Host institution

HELSINGIN YLIOPISTO
Net EU contribution
€ 1 498 621,00
Address
FABIANINKATU 33
00014 Helsinki
Finland
Region
Manner-Suomi Helsinki-Uusimaa Helsinki-Uusimaa
Activity type
Higher or Secondary Education Establishments
Links
Total cost
€ 1 498 621,00

Beneficiaries (1)