Black holes provide a unique battleground where fundamental principles of physics clash. Hawking calculated 45 years ago that black holes permanently destroy information that falls into them, violating the principle of unitarity. In the decades since Hawking's calculation, strong evidence has emerged that quantum gravity effects neglected by Hawking rescue the principle of unitarity, allowing information to escape form black holes.
However, the price of restoring unitarity is steep: we must give up at least one of two other cherished principles. Either black holes must violate causality, allowing signals to travel faster than the speed of light. Or, they must violate the equivalence principle, the foundation of Einstein's theory of general relativity, and burn up infalling observers at their event horizon.
In this project, we will quantify, for the first time, the extent of this conflict. How large must the violations of causality or the equivalence principle be in order to rescue unitarity? And can these quantum gravity effects be measured observationally?