The central research question framing this project is: how did notions of solidarity, sovereignty and sanctuary influence the experience and reception of boat refugees across time and space? A related sub-question is: who hindered and who helped boat refugees on their journeys, and why? The sea is used as a space of analysis to help answer such pressing questions.
This project's understanding of solidarity relates to people's willingness to support others, especially in times of need. Sovereignty relates to a state’s authority to regulate its borders. Sanctuary relates to whether and how receiving states provide safety to prospective boat refugees.
The PI’s project comprises a more general global history of boat refugees since the 1940s. The project also consists of three other sub-projects that involve case studies of 1) Vietnamese refugees in the South China Sea, 1975-1991, 2) Cuban and Haitian refugees in the Caribbean, 1980-1994, 3) Iraqi, Iranian and Afghani refugees in the Indian Ocean who attempted to reach Australia, 1999-2013. These will examine the experience of boat refugees and their reception. All four team members will be guided by the following parameters:
Part 1: Solidarity Onboard? Unity and disunity onboard refugee boats
Part 2: Solidarity at Sea? Boat refugees’ encounters with non-state actors at sea
Part 3: Sovereignty at Sea: Studying the sea as a policy venue
Part 4: Sanctuary after the Sea? Boat refugees’ transition to land
In relation to part 1, what role did ethnicity, nationality, gender, religion, colour, capital, and class play onboard the boats that refugees sailed on? What kind of solidarity did boat refugees express at sea, particularly when faced with extremely trying circumstances? Some of the questions posed for part 2 relate to the actions of private vessesls, such as merchant ships, oil tankers, fishing boats, and boats used by NGOs for search and rescue missions. Why did some help boat refugees while others ignored them? Did commercial vessels receive instructions on how to act from their companies and different governments? What does this tell us about how the duty to rescue works in practice? For part 3, SOS predominantly focuses on the actions of states towards boat refugees at sea. Grotius argued in the early seventeenth century that the seas were mare liberum because they ‘lie open to all by nature’ and the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) codified such a notion. But the high seas represent a problematic and ambiguous legal space. Therefore, SOS asks whether authorities have used the high seas as a policy venue to avoid national and international constraints? Part 4 places particular emphasis on determining what kind of asylum, if any, boat refugees received. What type of sanctuary did boat refugees obtain after taking to the seas and oceans and how and why did their experiences differ across time and space?
Anthropologists, security specialists, political scientists, IR experts, geographers, and legal scholars, in particular, have written extensively on boat refugees. Their focus is, understandably, given what has happened on the Mediterranean in recent years, very contemporary. Historians producing global and regional histories have generally neglected refugees. Yet various parts of the world encountered situations involving boat refugees before. What type of experience did boat refugees have then compared to now? How did states and regions react previously? What lessons can be learned for the present? Are ongoing events in the Mediterranean today really unprecedented? A global history of boat refugees since the 1940s, the first of its kind, is crucial to answering these questions.
By drawing on oral and written testimonies of boat refugees to articulate their experience, this project aims to place refugees at the centre of the analysis. The impact that other non-state actors have on boat refugees’ experiences will also be examined. These include smugglers, fishing boats, merchant vessels, and NGO search and rescue missions.