Skip to main content
Go to the home page of the European Commission (opens in new window)
English en
CORDIS - EU research results
CORDIS

Navigating the Marketplace of Indicators

Project description

Studying organisation handling of country performance indicators

In recent years global governance has seen the introduction of numerous country performance indicators across various policy fields aimed at measuring and ranking states or sectors to provide policymakers with crucial data. While this approach initially offered significant benefits, the rapid proliferation of indicators has led to an overabundance, with multiple indicators focusing on the same phenomenon within different fields, resulting in complications and confusion. The ERC-funded Navigator project will examine how private and public bodies handle policy fields filled with multiple indicators of the same phenomenon and how these approaches change over time. The project will focus on global governance, climate policy, education, and pandemic preparedness.

Objective

Most policy fields in global governance have an abundance of country performance indicators (CPIs) and new CPIs proliferate apace. States are now measured and ranked on a dizzying array of cross-cutting metrics. Prima facie, the era of indicators promises a revolution: armed with ever improving data, policymakers can better allocate scarce resources to address global challenges. Yet, the era of indicators generates a problem and a paradox: while each individual CPI strives to simplify complexity, an abundance of CPIs on the same issue multiplies complexity and thus generates ambiguity. Moreover, while it would be reassuring if we could assume only the soundest CPIs would thrive, many high-profile CPIs remain in widespread use despite well-known shortcomings.Crucially the paradox begets a major puzzle that prior research has yet to consider: How do private and public bodies navigate policy fields populated with multiple indicators, each portending to measure the same phenomenon? Although prior research provides firm grounds to hope that CPI users and producers improve their practices over time, no studies have investigated whether they do. Rendering this gap tractable, Navigator investigates the “marketplace of indicators” in four major policy fields: education, global governance, climate policy, and pandemic preparedness. Navigator’s novel framework—inspired by the classic liberal theory of the marketplace of ideas—enables the systemic, longitudinal analysis of how users’ and producers adapt their practices over time: Whether users learn in light of criticism of their favoured CPIs, how they discern when faced with a diversity of CPIs; and how producers compete for users within crowded policy fields. In this way, Navigator would push the frontier of CPI research by conducting a systematic problem shift: from investigating a single CPI’s influence or limitations, to examining how users and producers adapt in the face of growing CPI competition and CPI critique.

Fields of science (EuroSciVoc)

Keywords

Programme(s)

Topic(s)

Funding Scheme

HORIZON-ERC - HORIZON ERC Grants

See all projects funded under this funding scheme

Call for proposal

(opens in new window) ERC-2024-STG

See all projects funded under this call

Host institution

NORSK UTENRIKSPOLITISK INSTITUTT
Net EU contribution
€ 1 499 970,00
Address
ROSENKRANTZ' GATE 22
0176 OSLO
Norway
Region
Norge Oslo og Viken Oslo
Activity type
Research Organisations
Links
Total cost
€ 1 499 970,00

Beneficiaries (1)