SO-CUP represents a major push forward in our understanding of the mechanisms driving the Southern Ocean carbon sink, by expanding and re-drawing the current theoretical framework of the Southern Ocean circulation and carbon sink, improving our capacity to anticipate future changes in response to climate change.
The existing framework for interpreting the Southern Ocean carbon sink is based on a simplified, zonally- and time-averaged view of the Southern Ocean circulation. In this view, SAMW – main drivers of the carbon drawdown – originate from the old, deep Circumpolar Deep Waters (CDW) sourced in the North Atlantic, which upwell to the ocean surface around Antarctica and travel northward across the ACC. Instead, the SO-CUP findings show that the sources of SAMW follow complex 3-dimensional pathways and include a major, previously unaccounted, subtropical contribution.
Critically, in the existing framework, the Southern Ocean carbon sink is viewed as the result of thermodynamic forces imposing a net carbon uptake in upwelled CDW, which were last exposed to the atmosphere decades ago, when atmospheric CO2 was much lower. This interpretation is at odds with the lower carbon concentrations in SAMW with respect to CDW, and with CDW being oversaturated with respect to the present-day atmosphere, due microbial activity in the deep ocean. SO-CUP reconciles these facts by showing that biological uptake in surface waters drives CO2 concentrations below local equilibrium, allowing for a net intake from the atmosphere. SO-CUP thus places the biological carbon pump at the forefront of the processes driving the carbon sink and highlights the need of further research on the sensitivity and feedbacks of biological processes on climate.
Further, the existence of a large subtropical source of SAMW revealed by SO-CUP has implications for global ocean productivity. SAMW are believed to fertilise the global surface ocean by redistributing Antarctic nutrients across the World’s Oceans. SAMW nutrient concentrations, controlling global biological productivity, are thought to depend on the strength of biological nutrient drawdown in the Southern Ocean. Instead, our findings point out to a strong influence of the nutrient-poor subtropical sources of SAMW, suggesting that other processes (subtropical gyre circulation strength and across-ACC mixing processes) play also an unaccounted role.