- We investigated the effects of turbulence, using an oscillating grid apparatus, on growth and ingestion in Strombidium sulcatum feeding on picoplankton-sized prey. In batch cultures of ciliates feeding on bacteria, subjected to 4 levels of turbulence ranging from epsilon = 0.005 2.0cm{2} sec{-3} or still water, we found a negative, near-linear, effect of turbulence on growth rate. Examination of turbulence-incubated cells showed no evidence of arrested cell division, known from some dinoflagellate species. Ingestion rates, measured using fluorescent microspheres, were lower under turbulent conditions. A prey selection experiment with microspheres of different surface qualities showed similar, previously established, patterns of selective ingestion but at lower rates under turbulent conditions. Based on a mathematical model we believe that turbulence affects predator-prey contact rates and suggest that turbulence causes changes in swimming speed or pattern in planktonic ciliates which results in lower ingestion rates, leading to lower growth rates.
- To test the effect of turbulence on respiration rates we incubated batch cultures of Strombidium sulcatum feeding on heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) and bacteria as well as pre-screened cultures in BOD bottles, using an orbital shaker. Respiration rates were significantly higher under turbulence and correlated significantly just with HNF. Confirming previous results, turbulence had a negative effect on ciliates through higher respiration rates and lower growth with respect to the still control.
- Turbulence effects were examined with natural communities. Natural communities of ciliates and their prey were incubated either unaltered or diluted with filtered (algae-free) seawater. No significant effects of turbulence were evident.
- Data on the diversity of a sub-group of marine planktonic ciliates, tintinnid ciliates, were analysed to determine if a direct effect of turbulence (in the form of water column structure) could be demonstrated. We found that turbulence could not be shown to have a direct effect on tintinid diversity.
In summary, we discovered negative effects of turbulence on a marine ciliate but found no significant effect of turbulence, in and of itself, on natural, mixed species assemblages of marine ciliates. In the light of these findings we conclude that direct effects of turbulence on the growth of the natural ciliate communities need not be considered in models of planktonic food webs in which mixed species assemblages of ciliates are treated as a uniform group. However, our results with species of Strombidium sulcatum showed that turbulence could have a strong negative effect on certain ciliate species. Therefore, in systems in which the ciliate community is composed of a few species, for example in wastewater treatment tanks, turbulence may, through a particular species have a large effect on any process (bactivory, etc.) mediated through ciliates.